What’s the most famed line in the background of monetary policy? surely the close up door cadence of william Jennings Bryan’s decided at the 1896 autonomous convention: “We will answer their need for a gold traditional by speak to them:…you shall no crucify mankind ~ above a cross of gold.”


The funny thing around this heat is the for all its fame, we assume it verified a loser for Bryan and also his supporters, the “Populist” soup of the autonomous party. After ~ all, Bryan would lose the presidential election in 1896, and also again in 1900 and 1908. Moreover, the gold standard remained official policy right into the twentieth century, to the consternation that Bryan supporters, the prairie farmers who wanted straightforward money to buy farm yard equipment and also land.

You are watching: Why did farmers oppose the gold standard?

Yet quickly enough, Bryan and the Populists not only got every little thing they had pressed because that in 1896; what they obtained in terms of the evisceration that the gold standard gone beyond their wildest dreams. And it did nobody any kind of good. We’d execute well come remember this the next time a call for sound money elicits one of the inescapable references to “the overcome of gold.”

In 1896, Bryan opposed the gold standard since it had synchronized with the 1-2% per year deflation the the nation had been experiencing because the 1870s. Every point of deflation included a point of attention on debts, and also farmers were prone to have lots the debt. The expense of their inputs bought with funding was constantly going up. If over there were huge dollar production external the strictures of the yellow standard, Bryan and also the Populists reasoned, deflation would certainly be erased and the farmers could breathe easy.


Come the creation of the commonwealth Reserve in 1913 – with 5 of the twelve Fed banks down the stems of the prairie, native Minneapolis to Dallas – a big new federal college was ready to litter money around. And that that did. Native 1913 to 1919, the Fed doubled the dollar supply as the economy barely flourished at all. Whatever Bryan was obtaining at in 1896, he no bold sufficient to say that the dissension float need to be suddenly enhanced by 100%.

Technically, this mega-printing occurred under the auspices of the gold standard, in that the united state amassed substantial gold credits from abroad as it continued to be neutral in world War I. But suitable adherence to a gold conventional would have actually “sterilized” this credits, i.e., calculation them not to be supplied for financial purposes, on account of the production stoppage in Europe. The temptation verified too an excellent for the newbie Fed, however, what through its prairie plurality, and also all the brand-new Euro-gold to be monetized.

Dollars were showering the land, the overcome of gold was history, and somehow farmers only got killed as never ever before. The doubling of the money supply increased the price level by a factor of two, halving the actual income and assets that farmers, no to cite everyone else. Debt company was cheaper, however the points credit might buy cost twice as much. That is well-known also today in the Midwest that the 1920s were together desperate a te as went the livelihoods that farmers together any, including the an excellent Depression years of the 1930s.

Bryan had actually been completely wrong the the gold typical bore responsibility for the difficulties of farmers. Together late as 1915, 65% that Americans to be still living in landscape areas, also though mechanization and other developments had phenomenally increased farming efficiencies. There just was no longer need because that so lot farm labor. Farmers made decision to stick it out, however, and also not relocate to where the genuine employment activity was – cities. Because of this demographic stickiness, the labor force of America’s industrial revolution had to be imported from eastern Europe and Asia. The Pioneer era that staking cases to west land had actually taken location only a generation before Bryan’s speech; farm families thought the embarrassing to rotate tail on your parents’ homesteads and return to the seaboards for employment.

One that the factors the Fed was produced in 1913 to be to give ear come the concerns, such as they were, the the down-and-out farmers. Yet the copy of the dissension float go nothing to change the real economics of agriculture in a modernized economy. Instead, the result of the Fed policy was come visit wild gyrations on the price level – and hence the worths of legacy – ~ above the nation as a whole, i m sorry culminated in a great Depression because that everybody, farmer and also non-farmer alike.

That the “cross of gold” line continues to it is in the rhetorical swipe of choice against any type of advocacy for a collateralized dissension not just plays a role in depriving this nation of the salutary, gold-based monetary system it deserves. The perpetuates misunderstanding the the great achievements of our country industrial transformation and provides common reason with the mistake of the past.

See more: How Many Sweet N Low Packets Equal A Cup Of Sugar Substitution Charts


*

I’m a scholar -- the Richard S. Strong Scholar at the Laffer center -- who’s interested in ours economic history and the concept that entered making it, for good or ill. Top top this column, referred to as Past & Present, i write about how history can aid illuminate the economic challenges we confront today, and also how an extremely often historical sources execute validate free-market economics. I’m author of what’s currently the standard history of supply-side economics, "Econoclasts: The Rebels that Sparked the Supply-Side change and revived American Prosperity" (2009). I have a Ph.D. Native Harvard and also live in the game funding of the Americas, Houston. Various other experience has a year at the college of Colorado Boulder, wherein I to be the Visiting Scholar in Conservative Thought and Policy. Several years ago, Larry Kudlow and also I released a book on the history of the great John F. Kennedy taxation cut and also its influence on both the 1960s and also the 1980s, "JFK and also the Reagan Revolution: A Secret background of American Prosperity" (Portfolio, 2016).