You are watching: Who is rab in the half blood prince
There were 2 years in between the publishing of Prince and Hallows throughout which the identity of the locket thief may have been uncertain. Go the harry Potter fans deduce R.A.B."s identity? carry out we understand this indigenous statements the were certainly made before the publishing of Hallows? were there any interesting alternative theories? Or walk the fans easily settle right into a agreement that the locket thief to be Regulus?
enhance this question
inquiry Apr 2 "20 in ~ 1:17
30.9k1616 gold badges121121 silver badges345345 bronze badges
include a comment |
1 answer 1
energetic oldest Votes
With a fanbase as huge as bother Potter"s is, there"s never ever a complete agreement on anything, of food - but pretty much from the start "RAB = Regulus Black" was the frontrunner theory, v only tiny pockets of pan speculating anything else.
Take a look, for example, in ~ this Mugglenet post published only 4 days after the relax of the HBP, which nice prescient both in the general and certain details the RAB"s identity:
Now that I have actually laid out the criteria I believe our secret R. A. B. Needs to follow, I will certainly state that I believe the person is: Regulus Black, Sirius’ younger brother...
I think Regulus probably had more courage than Sirius offered him credit transaction for. I have actually a feeling that Regulus discovered himself in a situation comparable to what Draco Malfoy gained himself right into in HBP. Regulus more than likely did get scared, yet unlike Draco, he refuse to perform what Voldemort was asking him come do and actually tried to aid the future vanquisher ruin Voldemort. The takes a most guts come go versus Voldemort, and also I have a feeling Regulus knew he can never hide from Voldemort, and also if he was going come die, that did not want to do it cowardly however was walk to shot to do something that would certainly be terrible to Voldemort.
I think the is likely that bother will involved figure out who the mysterious R. A. B. Is through either Sirius’ residence or Kreacher; both of i beg your pardon he has actually conveniently inherited. I think the Harry will again find assist in a person that that was not expecting.
Or this 2006 past Hogwarts article, i beg your pardon guesses not just at RAB"s identification but practically every information of exactly how the locket plot would eventually go down:
So, whereby is the actual locket now? Regulus" note says the intends to ruin it as shortly as that can, however we don"t understand for sure that that did.
If it"s anywhere, you"d doubt it"s someplace in Grimauld Place, whereby we i think Regulus lived through his parents. In take care of Potter and the stimulate of the Phoenix, as soon as they are cleaning out the parlor in Grimauld Place, a locket is mentioned, yet only briefly... It"s a good chance the locket Harry experienced in the room in Grimauld ar was the locket. But, wherein is it now?
Some fans believe Kreacher has actually it.
Even the human being who argued versus it did so mostly on the grounds the "it"s as well obvious" or "it"ll it is in unsatisfying" rather than having alternative theories come propose.
Take, for example, this august 2005 short article from a "RAB is no Regulus Black" supporter:
The idea that Regulus black is RAB is by much the most renowned conclusion and there seems to be several things that pop increase confirming the theory.
Hands up, ns don’t have any sort the argument against Regulus black color being RAB, apart from my gut emotion that that so noticeable that it can not be true.
Or this early on 2006 forum post:
I never thought Regulus black was RAB. That would certainly be would be too lot in your face approach, unRowlinglike. She place something in your confront at first but always debunks the afterwards
(And shoutout come this person, that while arguing against "RAB = Regulus Black" managed to randomly guess a pretty big plot point involving Kreacher):
No means is it Regalus. It simply seems so... Stupid and unlikley. Just due to the fact that his initials fit... But i think KReacher to be there and was compelled to drink the potion, and also that"s why that is a tiny mad. It to be too lot for a House-elf come take.
A couple of places opened themselves approximately fun alternating theories (I think, "RAB is Dumbledore, time travel to the future" is my favorite) yet none obtained much traction amongst the broader fanbase.
See more: List Of D Gray Man Episode 52 English Dub, When Is The Dub Of 52
In the weeks and days counting down to DH"s release, the concept went even an ext mainstream, arriving on multiple non-HP media sites. It"s for sure to say that by DH"s release, the only world not expecting this twist to be the ones that either didn"t follow speculation at all or had a niche alternating theory.