You are watching: Do copper nails really kill trees

go to:Guardian countless homeUK newsWorld newsComment is free blogSport blogArts & to chat blogPodcastsIn picturesVideo----------------------Archive searchArts and also entertainmentBooksBusinessEducationGuardian.co.ukEnvironmentFilmFootballJobsKatine appealLife and styleMediaGuardian.co.ukMoneyMusicThe ObserverPoliticsScienceShoppingSocietyGuardian.co.ukSportTalkTechnologyTravelBeen there----------------------AudioEmail servicesSpecial reportsThe GuardianThe northernerThe wrap----------------------Advertising guideCompare finance productsCrosswordFeedbackGarden centreGNM press officeGraduateGuardian BookshopGuardianEcostoreGuardianFilmsHeadline serviceHelp / contactsInformationLiving our valuesNewsroomNotes & QueriesReader OffersSoulmates datingStyle guideSyndication servicesTravel offersTV listingsWeatherWeb guidesWorking because that us----------------------Guardian AbroadGuardian WeeklyMoney ObserverPublicLearnGuardian back issuesObserver ago issuesGuardian skilled

CategoriesNooks and also cranniesYesteryearSemantic enigmasThe body beautifulRed tape, white liesSpeculative scienceThis sceptred isleRoot of every evilEthical conundrumsThis sporting lifeStage and screenBirds and also the bees dangerous SCIENCEMy uncle believes that by embedding a item of copper in the trunk of a tree, you will certainly kill the tree? Is the correct? mine FATHER-IN-LAW recommend me a few years ago to hammer copper nails right into some trees in mine garden in bespeak to death them (I had too many). Once he inquiry for some copper nails at a hardware shop the assistant asked that if he want to kill part trees, so ns imagine there must be some substance to this theory. Lynda Labuhn, Bruehl, Germany (labuhn
t-online.de) NO. MINUTE amounts of copper might dissolve and pass right into the sap flow up v the trunk, but plants are quite tolerant of low concentrations - in fact copper is actually required by plants, together a ingredient of part proteins essential for photosynthesis. And high concentrations of copper salts have long been used to spray on plants as effective fungicides (e.g. Bordeaux mixture - copper sulphate and lime). At finest the copper object may assist to inhibit fungal assault near the wound, which would usually heal v time. Of food the copper might be a trouble later if the tree is sawn for timber. Ken Joy, (lsrak
csv.warwick.ac.uk) THIS may be true if the piece of copper is the shape and also size the a huge axe. Wilhelm Hamlin, Ontario, Canada. During my years together a tree surgeon I have come across the "copper nail" myth many times. Part years ago, as soon as cutting up the trunk of a generally vigorous poplar, i came across a ring that copper nails. Number of inches within the wood, the tree had actually enclosed them and also carried on growing with no okay effects. Geoff March, Stroud, Glos. TO know the potential influence of embedding a poece that copper in a tree tribe on the lengthy term health and wellness of the tree, some basic plant physiology and chemistry needs to be considered. In order to death a tree, a toxin should interfere with cell department in the areas from i m sorry a tree grows - root and also shoot tips and the cambium, a ring of dividing cells inthe stem and roots. In addition, inhibition of a crucial process such as photosynthesis will have a similar deleterious effect. Implanting a item of copper in a tree trunk will only affect such an important processes if the copper is transported indigenous the implant come the roots and shoots. There are two courses that copper might take. The first is in the xylem, the woody organization that forms the bulk of the tree stems (wood) but also forms the key transport route for water indigenous the soil, via the roots to the leaves. Movement here is regulated by the price of water loss from the leaf and this procedure is regulation by stomata on the under surface of the leaf. Materials move passively with the flow of water, return those with a optimistic charge will resolve to an unfavorable charged sites in the wall surfaces of the xylem tissues. The phloem organization (bark) is very specialised and also is responsible for transport of products of photosynthesis from pipeline to shoots and also roots. It have the right to rapidly seal off any injured tissues. Copper indigenous an implant would should dissolve prior to it could move to root or shoots and affect plant vitality. The pH that the phloem and xylem sap is contempt acidic (pH 5 - 6) so some copper would progressively dissolve. Copper binds preferentially to the xylem tissue and shows minimal mobility together a cation. That readily forms stable organic complexes with small molecules such together amino acids and appears to relocate through the xylem in this form. These complexes are an extremely stable and may not dissociate in ~ the end of the carry pathway. If so, these will not quickly pass across biological membranes and also inhibit metabolic activity. Copper activity from leaves, via the phloem is an extremely slow so the redistribution via this tissue from an implant would also be slow. The slow rate of copper release from a metallic implant would be unlikely to cause far-reaching problems because that a healthy and balanced tree. As the main route to life tissue would certainly be via the xylem, the patterns of water movement within a tree would likewise be vital in the subsequent transport the copper. This vary with tree species - in part water ascends directly up whilst in others, water activity occurs in a spiral that verying pitch. Several implants would certainly be forced to make certain that all components of the tree crown were got to by copper. In conclusion, ns would think about it unlikely that a solitary copper implant would certainly prove fatal come a healthy tree; one old or currently debilitated tree may prove to be an ext susceptible. (Professor) Nicholas W Lepp, Professor of tree Sciences, Liverpool man Moores University, Byrom Street, Liverpool (n.w.lepp
livjm.ac.uk) Well..... That killed it! Mac, shrewsbury uk I had a young witch hazel tree in my garden for part years which to be flourishing, so much so the I necessary to support among the branches. Without really thinking around it, I offered a size of copper piping together a stake close to its roots. Once I noticed that branch had passed away for some mysterious reason it didn"t occur to me to eliminate the piping directly away. By the moment I walk the entirety tree had actually died. I have actually left the in the expect it might revive indigenous the bottom (without the piping there obviously) however I"m not positive as it"s usually prospering catkins in January and also so far...nothing. RIP tree. Jane, London UK to ~ Dr.Nicolas, together a researcher in Egypt horticulture institute ns am interested in copper and its motion in trees. I check out your elegant article of copper implant to kill trees. I"ll be an extremely glad to tell me around ways to hinder or avoid copper from entering or penetrating in trees for research study purposes. With finest regards Hamdy Elzayat, Cairo Egypt Copper salts and also ammonia are efficient at dissolve cellulose. This is how viscose and also cello tape space made. Cellulose is the main part of plants. Ns think this is the reasoning behind the idea. An instant cold pack and also some plain (no enamel) copper wire in a hole in the tree may work. Paul, columbus USA correct a copper spike into the trunk of a sawn turn off tree guarantee no re-growth, to death the tree that hasn"t been chopped under - use a knife and also cut the bark approximately the tribe a 2 customs strip fully around... The tree will die. DeeJay, UK add your answer

See more: A Major Factor That Distinguishes Chamber Music From The Symphony Or Concerto Is That Chamber Music

Privacy policy| terms & conditions| heralding guide| A-Z index| inside guardian.co.uk| about this siteJoin our dating website today